In SmartWings vs SwitchBot, SmartWings wins on fit and protocol choice while SwitchBot wins on convenience, according to Paul Hibbert, a smart home reviewer who found SwitchBot’s adjustable shades about £81 cheaper in his comparison but tied to a SwitchBot hub.
On Amazon on October 16, 2026, the SmartWings motorized roller shade started at $179.99 and the SwitchBot Roller Shade at $199.99 for its 22.8–31.5 inch size.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Specs Side by Side
Prices checked on Amazon Oct 16, 2026. I may earn a commission from links, at no cost to you.
| SmartWings Motorized Roller Shade (100% blackout) | SwitchBot Roller Shade | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Made-to-measure roller shade | Adjustable-width roller shade |
| Power | Rechargeable, 4–6 months per charge; optional solar (listed) | Up to 8 months per charge; optional solar (listed) |
| Control | Zigbee, Z-Wave or Matter motor options; Alexa, Google, HomeKit (listed) | App, voice, remote; Matter via SwitchBot hub |
| Fit | Custom size | Adjusts to 22.8”–31.5” windows (this size) |
| Price | $179.99 | $199.99 |
| Buy | Check price | Check price |
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: fit
SmartWings is made to measure, Paul Hibbert explains, so you measure each window carefully. Shane Whatley calls SwitchBot’s roller shade the first adjustable smart shade: you choose a size range and adjust it at home.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: smart home control
Paul Hibbert says SmartWings offers Zigbee, Z-Wave, Matter and Alexa motors, and he would choose Zigbee. Shane Whatley notes SwitchBot needs a SwitchBot hub to join Matter. If you already run Home Assistant or Hubitat with Zigbee, SmartWings slots right in; see Best Smart Home Hub.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: battery and noise
SwitchBot lists up to 8 months per charge, and Shane Whatley highlights its quiet drift mode and a solar panel with a light sensor. DIY Smart Home Guy says a SmartWings battery lasts 3 to 6 months per USB-C charge, with a solar option.
Which should you buy?
- Exact fit, blackout, Zigbee or Z-Wave: SmartWings Motorized Roller Shade (100% blackout).
- No measuring, already use SwitchBot: SwitchBot Roller Shade.
What YouTube Reviewers Found With SmartWings and SwitchBot
These points are paraphrased from the video transcripts and credited to each creator. They are the creators’ own findings and opinions, not mine.
- Paul Hibbert: SmartWings blackout fabric gave proper blackout in his room.
- Shane Whatley: SwitchBot’s extra-large shade fits windows up to 72.8 inches.
- Shane Whatley: a small SwitchBot with solar was just under $150 at recording, versus about $335 for a similar SmartWings.
- DIY Smart Home Guy: SmartWings can be installed DIY.
![The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot's NEW Roller Shades]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/N07k2ReRfog/hqdefault.jpg)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is SmartWings or SwitchBot cheaper?
It depends on size. Shane Whatley found SwitchBot cheaper at a small size; on Amazon, SmartWings started lower at $179.99.
Does SwitchBot work with Apple Home?
Through Matter with a SwitchBot hub, per Shane Whatley.
Which smart shade is better for blackout?
Paul Hibbert praises SmartWings’ blackout fabric.
Do I need to measure for SwitchBot?
Only to pick the right size range; it adjusts to fit.
Sources
- Amazon product listings for the products linked above, checked October 16, 2026
- Paul Hibbert: “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”
- Shane Whatley: “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”
- DIY Smart Home Guy: “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”
Related: SmartWings Review | Affordable Smart Blinds | Smart Blinds Cost per Window
Notes and disclosure
Note: Prices come from Amazon listings checked on October 16, 2026. Prices change often, so check the current listing. Specs are the manufacturers’ listed numbers unless a reviewer is credited. Test results and opinions quoted above come from the YouTube reviewers and sites credited in each section; prices those reviewers mention are as of their videos. I have not tested these products myself yet.
Affiliate Disclosure: If you purchase an item through the links on this page, I may receive a commission, at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting the channel.