In the Levoit Vital 200S vs Winix 5510 matchup, two of three testers picked the Levoit for quieter, cheaper running. At its fastest speed under 45 dB, the Vital cleaned a test room 14 minutes faster than the Winix, according to HouseFresh, an independent site that tests air purifiers in its own lab.
Air Purifier First, a YouTube channel that tests purifiers, also chose the Vital. Project Farm, a YouTube channel that buys every product it tests, tested the Winix but not this Levoit and ranked the Winix first among the purifiers it tried.
The Vital 200S-P costs $169.99 and the Winix 5510 $179.99 (Amazon listings, Oct 16, 2026). The Winix has separate carbon and True HEPA filters; the Levoit has a better app and a cheaper filter.
Levoit vital 200s vs winix 5510: Specs Side by Side
Prices checked on Amazon Oct 16, 2026. I may earn a commission from links, at no cost to you.
| Levoit Vital 200S-P | Winix 5510 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (Oct 16, 2026) | $169.99 | $179.99 |
| Amazon rating | 4.6 (15,519 ratings) | 4.6 (32,436 ratings) |
| CADR | Smoke 250 / Dust 254 / Pollen 289 CFM (listed, AHAM Verifide) | 253 CFM (per Air Purifier First); AHAM Verifide for 392 sq ft (listed) |
| Coverage | Up to 1,875 sq ft per hour (listed) | Up to 1,882 sq ft per hour (listed) |
| Filters | Washable pre-filter + bonded particle/pelleted-carbon filter (Levoit says HEPA-grade in Sleep Mode) | Washable pre-filter + separate carbon filter + True HEPA, plus PlasmaWave (can be turned off) |
| Sensor and modes | Optical particle sensor, Auto and Sleep modes | Air quality sensor with Auto mode |
| App | VeSync app, Alexa | Winix Smart app |
| Filter cost | $49.99 filter every 12 months (per HouseFresh) | $79.99 filter kit every 12 months (per HouseFresh) |
| Buy | Check price | Check price |
Who Should Buy Which
- Levoit Vital 200S-P: Best value pick: strong CADR for under $200, low running costs and one of the most polished apps.
- Winix 5510: Top-speed smoke and particle performer with separate (unbonded) carbon and HEPA filters.
My Planned Test
Planned test: I plan to run both in the same room, timing how long each clears cooking smoke at its quietest usable speed. I will add my results and my Home Smart video here when they are done. Until then, nothing on this page is a hands-on claim from me.
What YouTube Reviewers Found
These findings are paraphrased from the video transcripts and credited to each creator. They are the creators’ own test results and opinions, not mine.
- HouseFresh (Vital 200S vs Winix 5510): third-party CADR results gave the Vital slightly higher dust CADR and the Winix marginally better pollen and smoke. Both scored 0.0 ppb for ozone. The Winix lacks a child lock, timers and a lights-off button, and uses a gas sensor rather than the Vital’s particle sensor.
- HouseFresh: at the fastest speed under 45 dB, the Vital cleaned its test room in 46 minutes, 14 minutes faster than the Winix. It measured the Winix 15% louder at top speed and estimated the Vital 33% cheaper to run each year, so it named the Vital the clear winner.
- Air Purifier First: in a 320 sq ft room, both the Winix 5510 and the Vital 200S improved air quality by 96% in 60 minutes at max speed. At the lowest speed the Winix measured 40.2 dBA and the Levoit 41.0 dBA; at max, 65.7 vs 62.2 dBA. It picked the Vital as the better overall choice but called the Winix an excellent option.
- Project Farm (buys every product it tests): the Winix 5510 (about $180) came out on top overall. In a 30-minute smoke test it removed 3.9 million particles, versus 3.52 million for the original Coway Mighty (about $229) and 3.18 million for a Dyson (about $1,200). Its one downside was noise, about 63.1 dB on high.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, the Levoit Vital 200S or the Winix 5510?
HouseFresh and Air Purifier First both picked the Vital 200S for quieter performance and lower running costs. Both say the Winix is still a good purifier.
Which is quieter?
The Vital. Air Purifier First measured 62.2 dBA at max vs 65.7 for the Winix, and HouseFresh found the Winix 15% louder at top speed.
Which is cheaper to run?
HouseFresh estimated the Vital is 33% cheaper per year. Its filter cost $49.99 vs $79.99 for the Winix kit.
Which is better for smoke?
Third-party CADR gave the Winix a slight edge for smoke and pollen, per HouseFresh, and Project Farm ranked the Winix first in its smoke test.
Sources
- Amazon “Customers say” review summaries on each listing (AI-generated by Amazon from customer reviews), checked October 16, 2026
- Amazon product listings for the air purifiers linked above, checked October 16, 2026
- Amazon search results for “air purifier” (snapshot October 16, 2026)
- HouseFresh: “Levoit Vital 200S vs Winix 5510 – Battle of the Mid-sized Air Purifiers”
- Air Purifier First: “Winix 5510 Vs Levoit Vital 200S – Tested & Compared”
Related: Levoit Vital 200S-P Review | Winix 5510 Review | Best Air Purifier Under $300
Notes and disclosure
Note: Prices and ratings come from Amazon listings checked on October 16, 2026. Prices change often, so check the current listing. CADR and coverage figures are the manufacturers’ listed numbers unless a reviewer is credited. Test results quoted below come from the YouTube reviewers credited in each section. My own hands-on results will be added after my planned test.
Affiliate Disclosure: If you purchase an item through the links on this page, I may receive a commission, at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting the channel.