In SmartWings vs SwitchBot, SmartWings wins on fit, width and protocol choice, while SwitchBot wins on price and quiet operation, according to Paul Hibbert, a UK smart home reviewer who has used both. He worked out SwitchBot’s adjustable shade at about £81 cheaper with comparable options, but it needs a SwitchBot hub (Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”; SmartWings sponsored the video).
On Amazon on October 16, 2026, the SmartWings motorized roller shade started at $179.99 and the SwitchBot Roller Shade at $199.99 for its 22.8 to 31.5 inch size. Below, specs side by side, then what reviewers found on fit, control, battery, noise and cost.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Specs Side by Side
Prices from Amazon at time of writing. I may earn a commission from links, at no cost to you.
| SmartWings Motorized Roller Shade (100% blackout) | SwitchBot Roller Shade | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Made-to-measure roller shade | Adjustable-width roller shade you cut to size |
| Widths | About 16 in to over 100 in (DIY Smart Home Guy); 114 in max per Paul Hibbert | 23 in to 72.8 in in four sizes (Shane Whatley) |
| Power | Rechargeable, 4 to 6 months per charge; optional solar (listed) | Up to 8 months per charge; optional solar (listed) |
| Control | Zigbee, Z-Wave, Matter over Thread or Alexa motor options (listed) | Bluetooth; app, remote, voice; Matter via a SwitchBot hub |
| Fabrics | Many light-filtering and blackout fabrics | 100% blackout, gray or white |
| Price (Amazon, Oct 16, 2026) | $179.99 | $199.99 |
| Buy | Check price | Check price |
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Fit and Installation
SmartWings is made to measure, so you measure each window carefully. DIY Smart Home Guy, a YouTube channel about do-it-yourself smart homes, installed one in under 4 minutes: screw in two or three spring brackets and snap the shade in (DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”; SmartWings sent the shades in the video). His tip: measure every window, even ones that look identical, because a window an eighth of an inch smaller won’t fit. SmartWings sizes run in eighth-inch steps, and he recommends ordering fabric samples first.
Shane Whatley, a YouTuber focused on Apple Home setups, calls SwitchBot’s the first adjustable smart shade (Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”; SwitchBot sponsored the video and sent the shades). You buy a size range, then resize at home: set the width, mount a cutter end cap, and the app rolls the shade while you lower a blade. Then you trim the fabric, staple on the bottom strip and slide on the bottom bar. He was nervous about cutting, but it went easily and got faster with each shade. Paul Hibbert said he did not enjoy building the SwitchBot, while the SmartWings came out of the box ready to hook on (Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”).
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Smart Home Control
SmartWings offers Zigbee, Z-Wave, Alexa and Matter-over-Thread motors. Paul Hibbert bought Thread and said he would choose Zigbee next time. His practical tip: the Matter code is printed on the top and back of the shade, so record it before mounting (Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”). Once connected, he called it flawless, with less hassle in Home Assistant than SwitchBot, which routes through its own hub.
DIY Smart Home Guy found his Z-Wave motors outstanding on a Hubitat hub, and his Zigbee shade stable after moving it to a new hub (DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”). He controls them with Lutron Pico remotes.
SwitchBot shades are Bluetooth, so they need a SwitchBot hub for Matter, voice assistants and remote access. Shane Whatley used a Hub 2 to add them to Apple Home (Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”). Each shade comes with a physical remote, and he likes the separate wireless remote (about $20), NFC tags and grouping shades to move in unison. See best smart home hub if you’re choosing a hub.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Battery, Solar and Noise
- SwitchBot: about 8 months per charge, per SwitchBot via Shane Whatley, with a USB-C solar panel that adds about $30 and includes a light sensor for automations (Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”).
- SmartWings: 3 to 6 months per USB-C charge, per DIY Smart Home Guy, who had not needed to charge yet; a solar panel keeps it topped up (DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”).
- Noise: Paul Hibbert found SwitchBot’s quiet drift mode slow and quiet enough to run in his son’s bedroom, while he’d run SmartWings outside the room (Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”). DIY Smart Home Guy found SmartWings motors smooth and said a friend’s test found them about as quiet as Lutron (DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”).
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Cost
At recording, Shane Whatley priced a small SwitchBot with solar at just under $150 on sale, versus about $335 for a similar SmartWings and over $750 for Lutron Serena; the extra-large SwitchBot with solar was just under $230 (Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”). DIY Smart Home Guy said a comparable Lutron shade costs over $1,200, at least twice SmartWings (DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”). Paul Hibbert called SmartWings premium quality and the nicest blinds he has tried, with proper blackout (Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”). For per-window math, see smart blinds cost per window.
SmartWings or SwitchBot: Which Should You Buy?
- Exact fit, wide windows, fabric choice, Zigbee or Z-Wave: SmartWings Motorized Roller Shade (100% blackout).
- No precise measuring, lowest cost, quiet bedroom use, already on SwitchBot: SwitchBot Roller Shade.
Video: Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”. Embedded with credit.
Video: Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”.
SmartWings vs SwitchBot: Frequently Asked Questions
Is SmartWings or SwitchBot cheaper?
It depends on size. Shane Whatley found SwitchBot about half the price at recording; on Amazon on Oct 16, 2026, SmartWings started lower at $179.99.
Does SwitchBot work with Apple Home?
Through Matter with a SwitchBot hub, per Shane Whatley.
Which smart shade is better for blackout?
Both offer blackout. SwitchBot is blackout only; SmartWings offers blackout and light-filtering fabrics.
Which is wider, SmartWings or SwitchBot?
SmartWings: Paul Hibbert cites 114 in maximum versus 72.8 in for SwitchBot.
Do I need to measure for SwitchBot?
Only to pick the right size range; you cut it to fit.
Sources
- Amazon product listings for the products linked above, from Amazon at time of writing
- Paul Hibbert, “FINALLY… Smart Home Blinds You Can Afford | Smartwings”
- Shane Whatley, “The First ADJUSTABLE Smart Shades! [SwitchBot’s NEW Roller Shades]”
- DIY Smart Home Guy, “BUSTED! 7 Myths about smart shades—SmartWings motorized roller shade review”
Related: SmartWings Review | Affordable Smart Blinds | Smart Blinds Cost per Window | Best Smart Home Hub
Notes and disclosure
Note: Prices come from Amazon listings at time of writing. Specs are the manufacturers’ listed numbers unless a reviewer is credited. Reviewer prices are as of their videos; some reviewers received products from the brands. I have not tested these products myself.